Prevalence and Determinants of Mental Distress among University Students, College of Medicine and Health Sciences in Hawassa University, Ethiopia.

 

Sailaja Busi, Zewdie Oltaye, Ezez Aklile, Tesfaw Ayenew, Berihun Yimam, Kefyalew Wubie, Addis Kindie, Sinit Tesfaye

Hawassa University, School of Nursing and Midwifery, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, Hawassa,  Ethiopia-05.

*Corresponding Author Email: sailajabusi@gmail.com

 

ABSTRACT:

Background: Mental health is defined as the capacity to work, capacity to love and the capacity to play and for recreation. It describes either a level of cognitive or emotional well-being or an absence of a disorder. Mental health refers to a broad array of activities directly or indirectly related to the mental well-being component. Mental illness was not recognized as public health problem both in developed and developing countries until the recent period of time (WHO, 1994). But there was evidence that mental illness can lead to increased mortality; in particular, the risk of death by suicide in persons with depression or substance abuse was well described ( Gelder et.al, 1989).

Objective: The aim of this study was to assess the prevalence and determinants of mental distress among students of Hawassa University, Ethiopia.

Method: Institution based cross-sectional study design was used. Respondents were selected by simple random sampling method. A total of 327 students were included. Simple Random Sampling technique was used. The data was collected by using a self administered structured questionnaire which was adopted from World Health Organization (WHO).

Results: A total of 327 students participated (with the response rate of 95.4%). In which 258 (78.8%) accounted for males and 55( 16.8%) accounted for females. Mean age of the students in our study was 22.6 for both male and females with a standard deviation of 2.41. In this study different factors that determine mental distress among study subjects were identified. a higher level of mental distress was reported in females than males which is statistically significant with at 95% CI (Xcal (df=1)=5.95,P=0.015). Study year of the students were having significant association with mental distress (Xcal (df=1)=5.95,P=0.015).

Conclusion: The family living condition was found to be strongly associated with mental distress. Especially those respondents whose parents (both father and mother) lost had high prevalence (60%) of mental distress as compared to those whose parents live together (49%),%), live in different place(25%), divorced (37.5%),one parent lost(29%).

 

KEY WORDS: prevalence, determinants, mental distress.

 


 

INTRODUCTION:

Mental health is defined as the capacity to work, capacity to love and the capacity to play and for recreation. It describes either a level of cognitive or emotional well-being or an absence of a disorder. Mental health refers to a broad array of activities directly or indirectly related to the mental well-being component. According to WHO, the definition of mental health is," a being of wellbeing in which the individual realizes his or her own abilities, can cope with the normal stresses of life, can work productively and fruitfully and is able to make a contribution to his or her community. Mental distress is a collection of mental problems that may not fall under standard diagnostic criteria and are characterized by symptoms of insomnia, fatigue, irritability, forgetfulness,  difficulty in concentrating and somatic complaints (Goldberg et.al. 1992). But the self-reporting questionnaire (SRQ) is a screening instrument developed by the World Health Organization (WHO) to assess the symptoms of mental distress ( Cary et.al. 2002). Mental distress has a wider scope than the related term mental illness. Mental illness refers to a specific set of medically defined conditions. A person in mental distress may exhibit some of the symptoms described in psychiatry, such as: anxiety, confused emotions, hallucination, rage, and depression and so on without actually being ‘ill’ in a medical sense.

 

Mental illness was not recognized as public health problem both in developed and developing countries until the recent period of time (WHO, 1994). But there was evidence that mental illness can lead to increased mortality; in particular, the risk of death by suicide in persons with depression or substance abuse was well described ( Gelder et.al, 1989). In developing countries mental disorders were not regarded as life threatening problems, seems too insignificant, unworthy and lacking public health attention; because in these countries, morbidity and mortality due to malnutrition and infectious diseases were very common (Goldberg and Murray et.al, 1992,1996). Mental health has always been the Cinderella of health concerns in developing countries, even though health policy and international consensus defined health in its broadest context of physical, mental and social components for about last 30 years. A popular belief is that mental illnesses are of lower priority because they are not associated with disability or mortality. However, the evidence suggests quite the opposite. Although not stated as priority, mental health problem was mentioned in National Health Policy of Ethiopia; one of the important reasons was lack of data on the extent of mental disorders especially in higher learning institutions ( NHPE, 1992). Tertiary education has always been regarded as highly stressful. This stressful environment can exert a negative effect on the psychological and physical well being of the students mainly the undergraduate students. Eventually this results in poor academic performance and possibly a large number of psychological causalities.  There were very few studies on mental distress among University students in Ethiopia. Mental illness is now being recognized as a major public health problem throughout the world. Prevalence studies highlight the gravity of the problem and there by challenge the policy makers to take appropriate action and there were a few prevalence studies done on isolated population group (Giang et.al, 2010). A range of evidence was presented to demonstrate that mental disorders, in particular depression and anxiety and substance (alcohol) abuse were common, profoundly disabling, run chronic courses when untreated and can contribute to increased mortality (Murray et.al, 1996). The recent Global Burden of Disease ( Goldberg et.al, 1992) report listed the most important causes of disability as measured by Disability Adjusted Life Years, depression was the single most disabling disorder, accounting for more than one in ten years of life lived with disability. Whereas research reveals that, five of the top 10 causes of disability were mental disorders of which depression and alcohol abuse were the most important.

 

There was evidence that mental illness can also lead to increased mortality. In particular, the risk of death by suicide in persons with depression or substance abuse was well described (NHPE, 1992). In Ethiopia, mental disorders were reported to account for 11% of the total burden of diseases (Giang, 2012). Though limited and inconclusive, the mental distress prevalence of 21.6% to 32.6%was reported among adama and addis ababa university students in Ethiopia respectively (Yadeta et.al, 2013). Despite mental health problem was included in National Health Policy of Ethiopia, interventions against the problem were limited. The main reason is the lack of data on the extent of the problem ( NHPE, 1992). Various factors were reported to be associated with the development of mental distress among university students. Separation from pre-existing social support, frustration with academic challenges, social problems, and threats due to high expectations from parents; teachers were reported attributes of mental distress which could present variably in different contexts (Yadeta et.al, 2013). Psychologists identified some common reasons why college students experience academic problems; which includes, Motivation factors, inadequate time management, study skills social interactions learning disabilities, substance abuse and psychological Issues. A large number of students were struggling with the many demands of college life while also dealing unassisted with major emotional issues such as loss, depression, and anxiety. Undiagnosed and untreated, many of these kind of problems lead to academic difficulties or failure (Alem A, 2005)

 

METHODOLOGY:

Institutionalized Descriptive cross sectional study was conducted to assess the prevalence and determinants of mental distress among University students in Hawassa, Awassa, Ethiopia. Third and fourth year Students of Hawassa University were taken as study population. The sample size was determined using the single population proportion formula with the following assumptions: prevalence of mental distress = 32.6 % ( to obtain the maximum sample size), Degree of precision= 5%, Level of confidence = 95% (Z= 1.96), Non-response rate 10%, the calculated sample size was 327. And these subjects were selected by a simple random sampling method after listing the name of the students alphabetically as a sample frame. The number of subjects to be selected from each class room was proportional to the population size of the class room. The response rate was 95.4%.

 

ETHICAL CLEARANCE:

Ethical clearance was obtained from Institutional Review Board, Hawassa University. No materials were used during the study. Source of funding not applicable.

 

FINDINGS:

(a)  Socio- Demographic data:

Three hundred and twelve respondents were studied with a response rate of 95.4%. Mean age of the students in was 22.6 for both male and females with a standard deviation of 2.41. Of all the respondents about 189 (73.3%) of males and 35(64.8%) females were Orthodox Christians by religion. About 19(7.4%) of males and 8(14.8%) of females were Muslims followed by 42(16.3 %) of males and 9(16.7%) of females were protestants.

 

(b)  Distribution of Those Psychological Symptoms:

SRQ24 among the total respondents showed ranging between 0 and 24. In this study 52(20.2%) of male and 9(16.6%) of female respondents had no symptoms of mental distress at all ; 69(26.7 %) of males and 7(13%) of female respondents had got a score between 1and 3, fifty seven (22.1%) of males and 7(13%) of female respondents had got a positive symptom score between 4 and 6, twenty five (9.7%) of males and 3(5.6%) of females obtained score between 7and 10, nineteen (87.4%) of males and 6(11.1%) of females respondents got a positive symptoms score of 15 or more of the 20 SRQ items. The distribution of cut points and taking into account of 11 or more of the 24 SRQ24 items, about 55(21.3%) males and 21(38.9%) females had mental distress in the last 4 weeks.

 

(c)  Prevalence of Mental Distress:

The study had tried to look into the socio-demographic characteristics that might influence the prevalence of mental distress among Hawassa University students. The total prevalence rate of mental distress symptoms among third and fourth year regular students was 55 (21.3%) for males and 21(38.9%) for females, the prevalence rate for both sexes was 24.4%.Among  third year, 32(29.4%) males and 15(62.5%) females were exposed to mental distress. The prevalence of mental distress in third and fourth year students were 35.3% and 16.2% respectively .When it was categorized into each department; in health officers the prevalence rate was 7(23.3%) for males and 5(55.5%) for females, for both sexes 12(30.8%). In Nursing, among 38 male students 6 (15.8%) were prevalent of mental distress and from 12 females students 1(8.3%) were prevalent. In Midwifery, among 60 male students 11(18.3%) were prevalent of mental distress and from 10 females students 4(40%) were prevalent, a total of 15(21.4%) for both sexes. In Medical laboratory, no male students were prevalent for mental distress and 3 females students 3(100%) were prevalent. In Environmental health, among males 5(55.5%) were prevalent of mental distress. In Optometry, among male students 2(28.6%) were prevalent for mental distress and none of the females were found to be prevalent of mental distress. In Medicine, among male students 24(22.4%) were prevalent of mental distress and 16 females students 8(50%) were prevalent of mental distress(table-1).

 


 

Table 1: Prevalence of mental distress among male and female respondents  N=327

No

Mental distress symptoms

Male

Female

Agree

Disagree

I don’t know

Agree

Disagree

I don’t know

No

%

No

%

No

%

No

%

No

%

No

%

1

Headache

89

34.5

151

58.5

18

6.9

30

55.6

22

40.7

2

3.7

2

Poor appetite

64

24.8

182

70.5

12

4.6

11

20.4

41

75.9

2

3.7

3

Nervousness tenses & worry

69

26.7

136

68.2

13

5

18

33.3

32

59.3

4

7.4

4

Difficulty in ADL

51

19.8

191

74

16

6.2

14

25.9

38

70.4

2

3.7

5

Loss of interest

86

33.3

161

64.4

11

4.3

25

46.3

25

46.3

4

7.4

6

Easily tired

62

24

186

72.1

10

3.9

22

40.7

21

50

5

9.3

7

Unhappy

73

28.3

174

67.4

11

4.3

17

31.5

33

61.1

4

7.4

8

Stomach discomfort

79

30.6

168

65.1

11

4.3

17

31.5

32

59.3

5

9.3

9

Unusual thinking

78

30.2

169

65.5

11

4.3

20

37

28

51.9

6

11.1

10

Increased heart rate

57

22.1

191

74.1

10

3.9

21

38.9

29

53.7

4

7.4

 

Table: 2 Association of socio-demographic variables with prevalence of mental distressN=327

S .no

Variables

Total n=312

Mental distress

Frequency

%

Exposed

Not exposed

X2cal(df=i)

95 %CI

X2 tab(df=i)

95 %CI

p-value

Remark

1

Sex

Male

258

82.7

55

203

5.95

Df=1

3.841

P<0.05

*

Female

54

17.3

21

33

2

Age

19-23

237

75.9

55

182

1.369

 

Df=2

5.991

p>0.2

NS

24-28

73

23.4

21

52

>28

2

0.64

0

2

3

Study year

3rd year

133

42.6

47

86

15.57

Df=1

3.841

p<0.05

 *

4th year

179

57.4

29

150

4

Department

Health officer

39

12.5

12

27

7.128

 

 

 

 

 

Df=6

12.592

p>0.05

NS

Nursing

50

16

7

43

Midwifery

70

22.4

15

55

Medical laboratory

10

3.2

3

7

Environmental health

9

2.9

5

4

Optometry

11

3.5

2

9

Medicine

123

39.4

32

91

5

Religion.

Orthodox

224

71.8

58

166

3.3424

 

 

 

 

Df=5

11.070

p>0.05

NS

Muslim

27

8.7

7

20

Protestant

51

16.3

9

42

Catholic

2

0.6

1

1

I have no religion

2

0.6

0

2

Other

6

1.9

1

5

6

Marital status

 

Single

290

92.9

68

222

4.089

 

 

Df

7.815

P>0.2

NS

Married

11

3.5

4

7

Divorced

2

0.6

0

2

Others

9

2.9

4

5

7

Ethinicity

Oromo

72

23.1

17

55

8.404

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Df=8

15.507

p>0.05

NS

Amhara

143

45.8

37

106

Tigre

24

7.7

4

20

Wolaita

13

4.2

2

11

Harari

4

1.3

0

4

Sidama

7

2.2

1

6

Hadiya

7

2.2

1

6

Gurage

18

5.8

8

10

Others

24

7.7

6

18

8

Familly condition

Live together

228

73.1

49

179

12.481

 

 

Df=4

9.488

P=0.015(>0.05)

*

Live in different area

32

10.3

8

24

Diorced

8

2.5

3

5

One parent loss

34

10.9

10

24

Both parent loss

10

3.2

6

4

9

Monthly income

No income

18

5.8

8

10

3.332

 

 

Df=4

9.488

 

 

Df =4

p>0.05

NS

Less than100

29

9.3

8

21

From 100 to299

116

37.2

28

88

From 300 t0 499

87

27.9

18

69

500 and above

62

19.9

14

48

(* indicates significance)

 


(d) Factors Determining Mental Distress:

In this study different factors that determine mental distress among study subjects were identified. a higher level of mental distress was reported in females than males which was statistically significant with at 95% CI (Xcal (df=1)=5.95, P=0.015). Study year of the students were having significant association with mental distress (Xcal (df=1)=5.95, P=0.015). Third year students were more exposed to mental distress due to high academic work load , less experience on self-management of stress and other factors as compared to fourth year students. family living conditions ( live together, live in different place, divorced ,one parent loss and both parent loss) were found to have strong association with mental distress at 95%CI (Xcal (df=4)=12.48, P=0.015) especially those respondents whose parents (both father and mother)  were lost had high prevalence 6 (60%) of mental distress due to absence of communication during problem facing, less social and economic support to cover their educational expenses. There was no association between age of study subjects and having mental distress but age greater than 28 was found to be a protective factor for mental distress due to different factors which needs further study. In addition to this, there was no statistically significant association between mental distress and department, ethnicity, religion,  monthly income, and marital status (table 2).

 

CONCLUSION:

In this study, about one fourth (24.4 %) of the university students were found to have mental distress. Mental distress was found almost two times higher among female students (39%) as compared to male students (21%). The prevalence of mental distress in 3rd year students (35.4%) were two times higher than that of 4th year students (16.2%).  The family living condition was found to be strongly associated with mental distress. Especially those respondents whose parents (both father and mother) lost had high prevalence (60%) of mental distress as compared to those whose parents live together (49%),%), live in different place (25%), divorced (37.5%),one parent lost (29%). In this study, there was no significant association of mental distress with age, religion, ethnicity, respondents’ marital status, monthly income, and department of the respondents. Also abuse of substances like khat, alcohol, cigarette and sedatives had no statically significant association with mental distress

 

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:

Several people have indifferent and valuable ways contributed to the creation of this study. Their assistance and input is acknowledged with appreciation. Special thanks to Hawassa University, the interviewers, the interviewees, for support throughout the study.

 

REFERENCES

1.     Goldberg DP, Huxley P. 1992 Common mental disorders: a bio-social model. London; New York, Tavistock/Routledge.

2.     Carey Usher Mitchell, Mark La Gory, 2002. Social Capital and Mental Distress in an  Impoverished Community. City and Community, 1(2):199-222.

3.     World Health Organization (WHO), 1994. Users guide to the self reporting questionnaires (SRQ). Geneva. World health Organization.

4.     Gelder, M., Gath, D. and Mayou, R,1989. the Oxford Textbook of Psychiatry. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

5.     Transitional Government of Ethiopia, 1992. National Health Policy of Ethiopia. Addis Ababa. Transitional Government of Ethiopia.

6.     Giang KB, Dzung TV, Kullgren G, Allebeck P, 2010. Prevalence of mental distress and use of health services in a rural district in Vietnam. Glob Health Action. Jan 15;3.

7.     Murray, J. Lopez, A.D, 1996. The global burden of disease: A comprehensive assessment of mortality disability from disease, injuries and risk factors in 1990 and Projected to 2020, Boston. Harvard School of public Health, World Health Organization.

8.     Yadeta Dessie, Jemal Ebrahim, Tadesse Awoke, 2013. Mental distress among adama university students in Ethiopia: a cross sectional survey. The Pan African Medical Journal. 15:95

9.     Alem A, Araya M, Melaku Z et al, 2005. Mental distress in medical students of Addis Ababa University. Ethiop Med J.43 (3):159-166.

 

 

 

Received on 05.10.2015                Modified on 17.10.2015

Accepted on 25.10.2015                © A&V Publications all right reserved

Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research. 2016; 6(3): 356-360

DOI: 10.5958/2349-2996.2016.00067.7